Disputas y tensiones en la construcción de la verdad jurídica : las distintas versiones construidas alrededor de tres casos de violencia policial
No Thumbnail Available
Date
2012-12
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidad Nacional de Rosario. Facultad de Humanidades y Artes. Centro de Estudios Sobre Diversidad Cultural.
Abstract
Description
A partir del trabajo con una fuente judicial -el expediente-, en este artículo nos proponemos
analizar diferentes lógicas, saberes y dinámicas burocráticas que van construyendo y
expresando distintas versiones en un caso judicial. Particularmente, nos interesa acceder a las
lógicas de construcción de la verdad jurídica y a las disputas que se dieron en torno a ella entre
diferentes agentes estatales y no estatales -policías, funcionarios judiciales, abogados y víctimasa
partir de tres casos de utilización letal de la fuerza por parte de funcionarios de la Policía
provincial de Santa Fe, concretamente en la ciudad de Rosario. Este análisis permitirá señalar
cómo, obedeciendo al marco de relaciones en que se encuentran y posicionan determinados
agentes, las resoluciones judiciales pueden tomar caminos diferentes que el delineado
inicialmente por la versión policial.
From the research with a legal source –the record of a case-, in this paper we suggest analyze different logics, knowledges and bureaucratic dynamics that going to form different versions in a judicial process. Especially we pretend to access to the logics of construction of the legal true and the conflicts about this configuration between government and not government agents – police officers; court officers; lawyers and victims – from three cases of lethal use to the force of law from police officers to Santa Fe Police, specifically in Rosario city. This analyze makes it possible to point out how in front of the influence to certain agents, the court decision could take different ways that the initial police version.
From the research with a legal source –the record of a case-, in this paper we suggest analyze different logics, knowledges and bureaucratic dynamics that going to form different versions in a judicial process. Especially we pretend to access to the logics of construction of the legal true and the conflicts about this configuration between government and not government agents – police officers; court officers; lawyers and victims – from three cases of lethal use to the force of law from police officers to Santa Fe Police, specifically in Rosario city. This analyze makes it possible to point out how in front of the influence to certain agents, the court decision could take different ways that the initial police version.
Keywords
Versiones, Verdad jurídica, Violencia policial, Versions, Judicial true, Police violence